2014 Anime Villains Tournament Round 3, Match 11

[LuckySeven]

In this match-up we have:

Shou Tucker from the original Fullmetal Alchemist vs. The Anti-Spiral from Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann
vs.

[SpacemanHardy]

Even though the Anti-Spiral's overall actions are technically worse in the long run, the atrocities that Shou Tucker committed to his OWN FAMILY are horrifying enough that he gets my vote.

[7jaws7]

Yeah, also voting for Tucker. It's just really loathsome what he does; the Anti-Spiral isn't quite despicable enough.

[rosebrook]

Anti-Spiral is more of an entity and never really felt like full blown villain.
Shou Tucker's actions are more concise and more impacting on an emotional level.

[GalaxyCrisis]

I have to flip a coin for this one…...

Heads, so I vote for Shou Tucker.

[Firefly]

Voted for Anti-Spiral because of the scale of its actions, and because it has no votes yet. Tucker's really despicable, but I can't let Anti-Spiral fall without a single vote.

[Looneygamemaster]

Yeah, you know, a villain just being utterly despicable isn't going to appeal that much to me. I mean, it's a good quality to have, but a villain should also have some element of evil charm. The Anti-Spiral's not a shining example of that or anything, but I'll still vote for him over Tucker.

[LuckySeven]

It is quite the tough choice here, but for a character that isn't even a main villain, Shou Tucker just stands out in my memory more.

[DrewFace520]

The Anti-Spiral!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[visoredavenger]

voted for Shou Tucker