Hey this is shay8! 
If you're a D.Gray-Man fan, then have a chat with me about the anime or manga.
I was wondering who do you think has the Heart of Innocence? Damn question has being bugging me all day and I just gotta' ask what other people think... 
If you have any questions, please share.
If you're not very far in D.gray-Man, be careful of spoilers!!!! 
If no one wants to suggest anything then I guess I should voice my suggestion...
Well, as far as D.Gray-Man is now, Lenalee's innocence has acted on its own will. This lead the black order to suspect that she had the heart of innocence because this strange phenomenone has never happened before. But when they learned that Allen's innocence had also acted on its own will, the order was deeply confused; how could these two inncence act on its own accord. They were then lead to believe that either Allen or Lenalee has the heart of innocence but how could both innocence act this way as there is only one heart. One of my theorys is that the heart could be in two peices, one for Allen and one for Lenalee. I thought this because Allen and Lenalee fight stonger and better when they are close to one another...but its just a theory!!
No dude, I totally disagree with your theory that lenalee is part of the heart. I think she was the first
I haven't read the newest volume, but I'm assuming Allen's innocence is the heart because he is the main character and it seems very likely. However I do agree that your guess is highly probable
ANIME FOREVER!
"This world is dark and it's so hard to breathe... but in this instant, when i laughed along with you, I felt that breathing just got a little more easier."- Yu Kanda from D.Gray-man
But if Allen's innocence is the heart, wouldn't that make the story a little easy to predict? If it isn't Allen, it adds interest to the story.
but but the end of the anime/ ch 158ish explains why lenalee isn't the heart and kanda backs it up later in more recent chapters. also, ch 204ish explains why allen is definately the heart. soo~ and the twist in the storyline is the 14th. its smarter to have him be both the heart and a noah, much more interesting
i agree with the theory that Allen and Lenalee most likely each have a piece of the Heart. I also think that because of this, that neither one can die as long as the other one is alive.
ANIME IS AWESOME!!!
( And so is Vocaloids!! )
eh i'm starting to think that Cross may have been the heart/other piece or something like that. Allen and Cross are the only two i think can possibly be the heart. and nice blank comments there shay. and edit to your siggy, "don't stop, always keep walking" was
Yeah but I like it when Mana says it. And sorry about the blank comment! I don't know what happened there!!
ANIME IS AWESOME!!!
( And so is Vocaloids!! )