YOUR ANIME VIDEO COMMUNITY
30 replies [Last post]
Eresir's picture
Offline
Yasha Ape
Authenticated User
Joined: 04/15/2011
Posts: 913
Re: do *insert shonen title* flow without

It flows decently, but not quite as well.

Using Naruto as an example, the filler arcs have a better leadup to the timeskip, and it develops some characters, like Hinata and Gaara. Shippuden's fillers also develop the likes of Aoba and Okisuke, plus it introduces Utakata before the World War.

I haven't finished Bleach yet, but the Bounts are brought up again later as part of Ichigo's character development.

Some of One Piece's filler is material that Oda couldn't put into the manga, like how Usopp got his goggles.

___________________________________________

 

Currently watching: Berserk, Fairy Tail, Bleach, Naruto Shippuden, One Piece, Ghost in the Shell, Yugioh: Zexal, Yugioh GX, Gun X Sword

Currently playing: Final Fantasy IX

Masamune1492's picture
Offline
BECK Roadie
Authenticated User
Joined: 08/17/2012
Posts: 243
Re: do *insert shonen title* flow without

They flow decently enough. I watch Bleach mainly and haven't seen much of Naruto or One Piece. The Karakura Town Fight arc flowed pretty well even though the Zanpakuto Rebellion arc was inserted in the middle of Karakura Town Fight arc.

___________________________________________

 I will not touch your pen to your paper. I will not touch it to your red paper. I will not touch it to your black paper. The white man will not see my mark again on his paper for the rest of my days on this Earth! - Red Cloud

from Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee

Vata Raven's picture
Offline
Yasha Ape
Authenticated User
Joined: 02/09/2012
Posts: 929
Re: do *insert shonen title* flow without

...So, I wasn't insane when they cut off right int he middle of the main story line in Bleach. I remember I was watching it on Toonami and before they started the reruns, it stopped RIGHT when Grimm got cut down and when it came back on, another story line was going on. I think that's what turned me away from Bleach.

___________________________________________

“In order to protect something precious, you must find it first.”- Vata Raven

Soundmonkey44's picture
Online
Blade Child
ModeratorAuthenticated User
Joined: 04/14/2011
Posts: 4806
Re: do *insert shonen title* flow without

Yeah Bleach has oddly placed fillers, but thats mostly because the Anime adaption always caught up with the manga too fast, thats one thing that I've always disliked about shonen in general, they think they have to make a filler every time they catch up with the manga, I mean they could just take a break instead, but meh. I mean again I enjoy filler for the most part,I mean despite what some say theres nothing wrong with coming up with fun original stories for shonen heroes & heroines, but I do feel modern shonen anime depend on it far to often at times. Maybe some company should go and adapt a U.S. comic in long running shonen, surely 20-75 years of content would keep them away from filler for quite awhile! XD

Masamune1492's picture
Offline
BECK Roadie
Authenticated User
Joined: 08/17/2012
Posts: 243
Re: do *insert shonen title* flow without

@Soundmonkey44. That would be cool! Take Batman for example and make it an anime. They would spend their entire lives trying to animate it and still not be done. dumb

But for the most part, Bleach filler arcs have generally been interesting. I do agree that it's stupid to insert it in the middle of the storyline, but as long as it's placed at the right time, for example when a big fight is over and something major is resolved, then it's generally alright.

___________________________________________

 I will not touch your pen to your paper. I will not touch it to your red paper. I will not touch it to your black paper. The white man will not see my mark again on his paper for the rest of my days on this Earth! - Red Cloud

from Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee

Kazemon15's picture
Offline
Rice Ball
Authenticated User
Joined: 04/17/2011
Posts: 172
Re: do *insert shonen title* flow without

Yeah the random "Filler arc in random dimension X" was what made me stop Bleach too. That and the manga (for me) went downhill in general, but that's a different story....

I do remember my friend telling me that One Piece is notorious for having "recap arcs" instead of "filler arcs" .... like spend at least one season doing a recap from each character's POV... I wonder how Funimation will deal with that when the time comes...

For me, the only shounens that make filler flow and look good is Reborn! and FMA. (though Im not sure FMA can count since it can't be considered "long-running"?) The rest of the shounens....is...eh....I don't want to watch them. In Reborn's case, what people thought was "filler" was actually in the manga and what people thought was "in the manga" was actually filler, in a good way...XD

___________________________________________


A Katekyo Hitman Reborn! AMV

Eresir's picture
Offline
Yasha Ape
Authenticated User
Joined: 04/15/2011
Posts: 913
Re: do *insert shonen title* flow without

Quote:
Yeah Bleach has oddly placed fillers, but thats mostly because the Anime adaption always caught up with the manga too fast, thats one thing that I've always disliked about shonen in general, they think they have to make a filler every time they catch up with the manga

And unfortunately the creators normally just don't care, and that's a shame.

Fairy Tail has managed to get this far only having two filler arcs (one of which the creator wrote anyway) because Mashima puts out chapters quicker than most, or so I'm told.

I'm also told that Kubo always took/takes breaks when writing Bleach, which is probably why it has as much filler as it does.

Quote:
I do remember my friend telling me that One Piece is notorious for having "recap arcs" instead of "filler arcs" .... like spend at least one season doing a recap from each character's POV... I wonder how Funimation will deal with that when the time comes...

There were 6 horrible episodes like that right before the fights with CP9, but certainly not entire seasons.

Edited by: Eresir on 10/25/2012 - 1:13am. Reason:
___________________________________________

 

Currently watching: Berserk, Fairy Tail, Bleach, Naruto Shippuden, One Piece, Ghost in the Shell, Yugioh: Zexal, Yugioh GX, Gun X Sword

Currently playing: Final Fantasy IX

Vata Raven's picture
Offline
Yasha Ape
Authenticated User
Joined: 02/09/2012
Posts: 929
Re: do *insert shonen title* flow without

Eresir wrote:
And unfortunately the creators normally just don't care, and that's a shame.

It's not that they don't care, it's that they have no say in the matter on how the anime goes, unless they work with it.

___________________________________________

“In order to protect something precious, you must find it first.”- Vata Raven

Eresir's picture
Offline
Yasha Ape
Authenticated User
Joined: 04/15/2011
Posts: 913
Re: do *insert shonen title* flow without

They know that less filler is necessary when they put out more material.

___________________________________________

 

Currently watching: Berserk, Fairy Tail, Bleach, Naruto Shippuden, One Piece, Ghost in the Shell, Yugioh: Zexal, Yugioh GX, Gun X Sword

Currently playing: Final Fantasy IX

Soundmonkey44's picture
Online
Blade Child
ModeratorAuthenticated User
Joined: 04/14/2011
Posts: 4806
Re: do *insert shonen title* flow without

Eresir wrote:
They know that less filler is necessary when they put out more material.

Now your just being silly, Manga-Ka are hard working men & women that put out content as fast as they are able to, Kubo & Others already get hassled about the quality of their works degrading or stagnating as is, if they did it any faster all it would do is cause the fans to whine even more. Plus with more cartoony (and I mean that in a good way not a bad way) Shonen like Fairy Tail & One Piece you have more content to put in an episode more often then note, slower more action based shonen usually get plowed through in the anime adaption as it doesn't always take as long to tell the story in animation as it does comics.

And yeah manga-ka don't really have as much say as they would like when it comes to the anime adaptions of their works more often then not.

view counter