YOUR ANIME VIDEO COMMUNITY
26 replies [Last post]
RonsLegacy's picture
Offline
Rice Ball
Authenticated User
Joined: 09/10/2011
Posts: 11
Current State of Anime

So there is a lot of talk on YouTube stating that we as fans have to sustain the anime industry by picking up anime, and buying them every other week and what not. But there are also people who believe that watching anime online is also supporting it because it is giving it some sort of exposure to the masses. I personally feel that in order to keep something running or functional you have to get your self involved within that specific activity. So my question to you guys is how do you feel about this specific topic? (also we have to take into account the torrentors)

___________________________________________

YouTube me: Strappedup24 - is shooting for the stars but not mssing success 

SereneChaos's picture
Offline
Rice Ball
Authenticated User
Joined: 10/07/2011
Posts: 102
Re: Current State of Anime

I'm very frugal and I will never blind buy a DVD. So I always watch a series online before I buy it, and even then I only buy my favorites and usually wait for cheaper box sets. When I do buy a DVD, it's only partly because I want to support the industry/that show/whatever. It's mainly because I want to see it in my collection. But that said, I do watch almost only legal streams (with the exception of OVAs or other extras). That's due mainly to the fact that I feel guilty/stupid watching something illegally when it's just as easy to watch it legally. I live in the US, the legal stream sites work perfectly fine, the video quality is as good as it'll get on my laptop, and they're usually posted quickly and on a regular scheduled, so why shouldn't I watch stream?

But manga, which I read more of than watch anime, is another story. With the lack of free/legal options, I do read a lot of scanlations. I usually read about a volume or two of a series. After that, I decide that if I'm going to buy it if/when released in English, or drop it. If the series is currently being released in English, but it's very far behind, I usually read scanlations, then buy the volumes as it's released. If the series hasn't been release in English, I plan on buying it if it does. I also borrow lots of manga from my local library that I like, but not enough to buy.

Edited by: SereneChaos on 07/03/2012 - 12:46pm. Reason:
___________________________________________

7jaws7's picture
Online
Blade Child
SubscriberAuthenticated User
Joined: 04/16/2011
Posts: 4785
Re: Current State of Anime

Well when I first really got into anime a few years back, I just started buying DVDs of some of the more popular shows out there - although I only blind bought anime I knew I would enjoy. From there I mainly watched a mixture of must watch and easy-going anime through legal streams.

Truthfully though, recently I've been passing up a lot of popular anime like Madoka (though I did see it streamed) in favor of all the Strike Witches merchandise I've been buying. Technically I think that's still supporting the anime industry, lol.

___________________________________________

SS5ant's picture
Offline
Nobuseri Bandit
Authenticated User
Joined: 04/17/2011
Posts: 3044
Re: Current State of Anime

RonsLegacy wrote:
But there are also people who believe that watching anime online is also supporting it because it is giving it some sort of exposure to the masses. I

And those are the same people who got all mad that FUNimation quit the Case Closed dub. Exposure doesn't translate into sales and in the end that is the only thing that matters to the Japanese companies. No need to waste the studio's resources if it will end in a loss.

Soundmonkey44's picture
Offline
Blade Child
ModeratorAuthenticated User
Joined: 04/14/2011
Posts: 4821
Re: Current State of Anime

@Ron: So does this thread just pertain to the online distribution of anime or can we just rant about the medium in general?

Anywho, speaking purely of online distribution of anime, the amount of legally streamed shows has greatly increased over the past 5 years and steadily continues to do so, websites like Crunchy, Funi, Hulu, etc are giving fans a way to watch anime free & legally which is a good thing, also giving them options to pay if they want content sooner. And of course VIZ will soon be launching a streaming service for game consoles which will provided dubbed anime 24/7 for a reasonable price. Overall animes legal distribution in the digital realm is solid. however, despite this it will not stop people from illegally viewing anime (or any other form of media for that matter) merely because they have the ability and the apparatus to do so... or in more simpler terms, people are immature, entitled, & spoiled (specially in the U.S. & Japan where they have a lot of legal ways to get stuff), they have a way to get anything they want at the click of a button, they will take advantage of that, nothing will ever change that.

But ahh yeah, basically equal amount of both good & bad I guess on the digital front.

As for anime in general well, the medium continues to stagnate and degrade at the same pace it has been since around oh... 2005 or so, constantly pandering to the most base parts of the human psyche and the lowest common denominator of viewers &/or Otaku/weeaboo over focusing on quality story telling and character development. but honestly its nothing sup rising, television on the world scale in all genres of entertainment have arguably been either going down hill or stagnating for the most part for the past 7 years or so. Given theres still good anime (and TV in general) that pops up from time to time, but most shows could arguably be called fairly mediocre. But thats just my personal opinion.

And its not like Medicore shows can't be fun, I myself enjoy Highschool DXD & on the U.S. side of things still catch Spongebob from time to time, both are (or have become) Medicore media, but they can still be fun to watch.

But yeah i'm rambling, so ahh.... carry on gentleman tongue nervous (and ladies too of course.)

Edited by: Soundmonkey44 on 07/03/2012 - 2:43pm. Reason:
kaiju_wars's picture
Offline
State Alchemist
Authenticated User
Joined: 11/22/2011
Posts: 6737
Re: Current State of Anime

I usually watch a series first, and if I like it, I will buy it... and like half the stuff for it, usually hats though. I love collecting hats. kitty
I do buy blind. But for me that is, I go to Rightstuf.com and I buy random blind boxes, I found a few series I like, usually in volumes, and I did get one complete box set. But that is how I usually support the industry.

___________________________________________

The internet's biggest Sanya and Eila fan (self-proclaimed) P.S. Sanya and Eila are lovers.

Firefly's picture
Offline
GOTT Secret Agent
Authenticated User
Joined: 04/14/2011
Posts: 798
Re: Current State of Anime

I only buy the stuff I like. Redline was a blind buy, and I had only heard some info about and seen one episode of Madoka Magica before I decided I wanted to buy all 3 LEs. Those are the exceptions to my general pattern. Normally, I watch the show through streams, decide how much I liked it if at all, then look it up at my usual online shopping options (ie TRSI) to look at the price, then decide if it's worth the price.

But yeah, I agree with the idea that we, as fans, need to support the stuff we enjoy, even if it's just watching legal streams or buying a poster.

___________________________________________

MyAnimeList

"May those who accept their fate be granted happiness.  May those who defy it be granted glory."

-Princess Tutu

neonwalrus's picture
Offline
Thousand Master
Authenticated User
Joined: 05/09/2011
Posts: 1030
Re: Current State of Anime

Quote:
As for anime in general well, the medium continues to stagnate and degrade at the same pace it has been since around oh... 2005 or so, constantly pandering to the most base parts of the human psyche and the lowest common denominator of viewers &/or Otaku/weeaboo over focusing on quality story telling and character development. but honestly its nothing sup rising, television on the world scale in all genres of entertainment have arguably been either going down hill or stagnating for the most part for the past 7 years or so. Given theres still good anime (and TV in general) that pops up from time to time, but most shows could arguably be called fairly mediocre. But thats just my personal opinion.

Sorry guy, but disagree with you here - I have found there have been some great animes in different subgenres over the last few years - and yes, there has been crap, but there always has been crap. Some titles that I really enjoyed would include Princess Jellyfish, Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood, Shiki, Sekirei, Queen's Blade, Baka and Test, Samurai Girls, Highschool of the Dead etc. Now, I jsut ant to talk about anime itself here.

What I've found is even the fanservice titles have gotten good in terms of character and story development, it used to be they could have fanservice and nothing much else going on, but, to connect the current state of anime with these titles, it's more crucial than ever to ensure they're "giving the whole package" so to speak, meaning, story and characters are key, in order for an anime to be good, it has to have that foundation built on this. So, in simple terms, fanservice attracts veiwers, a good story and characters keeps them and provides sustainability to make way for sequel series.

There are a few reasons - first, people want to watch a show with characters that are dynamic, charasmatic and fun - essential, relatable characters that people care about, and villians they just hate. Be it an anime like Shiki, or Queen's Blade, the rules are the same, in terms of the fanservice, it's just icing, superficial layering to attract people - to keep them, you need that story and characters. And the fact they offend people - it ironically helps the series in some weird way.

Second - the trend I've noticed in anime, as well as big budget movies is that they're all looking for sustainable franchises - an anim or movie series that will last for a few good years, something they can make sequels to. It makes sense, think about movies like Harry Potter, Hunger Games, or the new Spiderman series - the original material is there - and there's LOTS of it, so it provides plenty of raw story material to mine - all they need to do is adapt it over to a movie without any need to have to come up with an outright original story. The same goes for anime, I'm seeing more sequels - Queen's Blade, Ikki Tousen, Inuyasha - Fina Act, Sekirei (it's pretty much guaranteed there will be a season 3 and 4) reboots - Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood, Berserk, and now; Sailor Moon. So when you look at these trends, we see reboots, fanservice and of course, stories and characters that have enough weight to establish success and provide further sequel series.

Now, on the business end of things, I'm hearing it's not so good, people are illegally downloading anime left and right with absolutly no intention of buying them - this is the problem right here - and these are the people that say English dubs suck, the original Japanese tracks are way better even though they can't speak a single sentence in Japanese let along a single word - save for baka or kawaii - these people drive me nuts.

My favorite is when they say they "have" or "own" a certain title, meaning they donwloaded it(not on itunes where you pay - like me cool ) I've actually encountered people like this and I say "You don't have Queen's Blade, I, have Queen's Blade, see, I bought the blu rays, I paid money for them, same with Shiki, Heavens Lot Property etc. you have files on a hard drive that are fake, counterfit, phony, not genuine, and they're worth.................f&ck all." I actually take offense when they trash Mr. Mignogna's protrayal of Edward on FMA, yeah buddy, say that too his face, and while you're at it, tell Mr. Willingham how you feel about his Roy Mustang - and see how many teeth you end up losing(that guy's a big f&cker - more like Mr. Cankillmeinonepunch).

What bothers me about all this though is that companies like Funimation are bending over backwards to accomodate fans with their free streaming service, and other resources they provide fans. Their prices for their blu rays, itunes(cheap) shows and DVD's are fair, not cheap, but fair, better than what they used to be, and there's a lot more bang for your buck on these sets with the commentaries and some of the special features they give. And yet, people still hate on the englsih dubs, refuse to pay money for the products, I don't get it. As civilized human beings does it not make sense that when you like something, you buy it which entails paying a certain amount of money for said product?

And people just need to buy what they want, with Funimation's service - the streaming and their youtube channel, it's easier than ever to buy anime risk free, that's how I went about buying Cat Planet Cuties and Princess Jellyfish, some others I saw a few clips and knew I'd like it - Shiki for example.

I do hope Funimation, Viz and Section 23/Sentai are able to stick around, I'm a consistant customer, and I'd hate to see a group of bad apples ruin it for all of us. I plan to buy more in the future for the record - I want the Yamada's First time (saw a clip and youtube - looks dawm funny), Freezing (I thought this was an anime about my computer at first - jokes), The World God Only Knows, Summer Wars, and maybe Chaos Head in the immediate future. Later on, I KNOW I want Ikkitousen GG and XX(thank you for aquiring this), Blood - C, Maken - Ki! (a bit silly, but fun), Queen's Blade Rebellion, look, I'm not going to list every single one, I think you get the idea.

Well, I've done it again, wrote an essay, but whatever, now it's time to eat and play bass - finished my school work already for the day.

___________________________________________

 

For Unlawful Carnal Knowledge 

Soundmonkey44's picture
Offline
Blade Child
ModeratorAuthenticated User
Joined: 04/14/2011
Posts: 4821
Re: Current State of Anime

@Neon: Oh yeah don't get me wrong theres still good shows I love the Noitamina stuff for the most part, so yeah i'd agree Princess Jellyfish & Shiki are spectacular series, as is Five Leaves, Bunny Drop, Fractal (minus the ending lol) etc. And then theres still studios like Madhouse that gave us beautiful adaptions of U.S. properties and great series like Rainbow & Tatami Galaxy. And Gaianax is still as crazy as ever with flat out insane shows like Panty & Stocking with garter belt, lol.

But yeah I guess the fan service stuff is always the point we will disagree on, I can admit it seems they at least TRY for the most part these days, but I find most are still just filled with flat generic characters and a storyline that is average at best. Given due to the genre/sub-genre they don't really need to do much, but yeah. Again i'm not saying its wrong to watch fan service, I enjoy Highschooll DXD & Strike Witches myself, but i'm not going to try to lie to myself and say their as well written or as well developed as say, Kids on the Slope or heck even Cowboy Bebop. But again thats just me.

neonwalrus's picture
Offline
Thousand Master
Authenticated User
Joined: 05/09/2011
Posts: 1030
Re: Current State of Anime

Quote:
But yeah I guess the fan service stuff is always the point we will disagree on, I can admit it seems they at least TRY for the most part these days, but I find most are still just filled with flat generic characters and a storyline that is average at best. Given due to the genre/sub-genre they don't really need to do much, but yeah. Again i'm not saying its wrong to watch fan service, I enjoy Highschooll DXD & Strike Witches myself, but i'm not going to try to lie to myself and say their as well written or as well developed as say, Kids on the Slope or heck even Cowboy Bebop. But again thats just me
]

As a fan of many of these type of anime (among many others) I have seen some fanservice animes as you describe here; they're boring, and servce only as a vehicle for boob, panty and swimsuit shots. THey bring nothing innovative or fun to the table, and like I said, aside from the naughty scenery, they have absolutely nothing going for them.

However, when I look at the ones that have a solid following, either sequel series keep getting made(Ikki Tousen, Queen's Blade), or people wish for more(Cat Palnet Cuties) these are animes where you can tell the people that made them realized, they aren't going to be able to get away with throwing a little ecchi to the veiwers to get them to bite.

We all know it helps, but, when you look at these particular shows (among a few others of the same genre) you see developed characters, a good story, something actually worth watching. However, because of other factors, they are not for everyone, which is perfectly okay - I think what bothers me is when people trash talk some of these titles and say the story and characters are as exciting as a cardboard box.

And no, Queen's Blade and Ikki Tousen are not as intricate as Fullmetal Alchemist or FMAB or Shiki on story and character development, but you must remember, those are some hard animes to top, even good animes that have no fanservice aren't much of a match for the calibur these titles fit into. For example Deathnote, good, but, I have to give both FMA series props over it.

What this has to do with the state of anime is that first, there isn't much of an increase in these fanservice titles if any - they have aways been there, however, they are now getting marketed more agressively. Second, because anime isn't on as strong a position as it once was, producers are understanding (as mentioned before) you can't just parade around a few underwear girls, or ripped males and expect your product to do well of possess any sort of sustainability they need good characters and good overall story consisting of relevant subplots.

So, in the fanservice genre, titles that are doing good, or have a large following are like this:

Ones I've seen - Queen's Blade, Ikki Tousen, Cat Planet Cuties, Girls Bravo, Samurai Girls, Heaven's Lost Property. Sekirei, Highschool Of the Dead, DearS, and others I have seen some of - Highschool DxD, Maken Ki!(this one isn't as good as others, but fun, they suckered some of us with this one), Freezing.

Others that people have mentioned, but I never got into would be Sekon No Qwasar, not really for me, but lots of fans of this genre love it.

When I think about fanservice animes that are not very good, or just plain boring, it's actualy more of the older series, as illustrated above, these titles give the audience the whole package, and they're more recent, and no, not for everyone. Older series that just didn't quite do it would include - Eiken, Nadjica, Agent Aika, Master of Martial Hearts(little newer). But do you notice how most of them last for only two or three episodes? There's not even enough substance there to carry a complete series, and most people, even the fans, dislike these shows.

I will say one thing that I do like about the state of anime now, at one time, every second release was a bloody mecha anime, and yes, there are some good ones, Neon Genesis wasn't too bad(little overrated in myopinion), but I'm not a big mecha person. Personally, I like comedies, fanservice, action/adventure, drama, period, suspense and even horror, stuff that's very character and/or story driven.

Another thig I have seen is more of a range of animes coming in, with many American companies disappearing or changing (Geneon, Bandai, Media Blasters? ADV -> Section 23) It seems as though the epicenter for anime in USA is in Texas, Funimation and Section 23 are there, I hear about VA's doing work for animes from both places (Brittney Karbowski, Monica Rial) so the point is this - these two major companies are going to be pretty busy with everything - marketing, dubbing, distributing simply because they're now picking up the slack for companies that no longer exist.

I remember when I thought of Funimation all that came to mind was Dragonball(don't care), Fullmetal Alchemist, Fruits Basket, One Piece, I never thought they would be working on animes like Sekirei, or getting Ikki Tousen, or even Shiki for that matter. So I think it's fair to say the business has changed considerably, and personally, I like it, so far Funimation and Section 23 have proven to be reliable in meeting their relese dates, notifying fans about titles, and making quality dubs.

I do hope that the industry globally (North America - Canada, USA, and Japan) does get a little more steam, but with that I only hope it brings about a wider range of titles that appea to everyone - as I mentoned, now that any of the distributors have gone the way of the dinosaur, Funimation, Section 23 and even Viz have a responsibility to the fans to make available for sale as many of the titles in as many subgenres as possible. And I do hope that the fanservice animes continue with this trend of actual character development and story telling.

PS - if there are any missellings it because my keyboard has been somewhat unresponsive and it "drops" letters - I practically have to hammer it with my fingers.

___________________________________________

 

For Unlawful Carnal Knowledge 

Renzokuken's picture
Offline
Sharpshooter
Authenticated User
Joined: 04/23/2011
Posts: 2044
Re: Current State of Anime

neonwalrus wrote:
However, when I look at the ones that have a solid following, either sequel series keep getting made(Ikki Tousen, Queen's Blade), or people wish for more(Cat Palnet Cuties) these are animes where you can tell the people that made them realized, they aren't going to be able to get away with throwing a little ecchi to the veiwers to get them to bite.

I think you might be working under a logical fallacy here. Argumentum ad Populum or "Appeal to the Majority" is a logical fallacy that basically boils down to: lots of people think X, therefor X must be true. Just because something is popular, doesn't make it good. It just makes it popular. And for the record, I don't think any of those shows you listed have anything close to what I would call a well-written plot or good characterization. I'm not expecting Madoka Magica levels of plot and characterization, but I'd much rather see shows try and fail rather than just be lazy and shallow.

Code Geass had tons of fanservice and an absurdly dumb plot(especially in R2), but it did a lot of things right. Lelouch and Suzaku are extremely well characterized and developed. I like to joke that they were written for a totally different story. The plot, while dumb, made sense in context, tried to tackle some tough themes and had a satisfying conclusion.

I'd have a lot more respect for fanservice shows if they just went the extra mile like Yosuga no Sora and were just softcore hentai, because that's pretty much all it is anyways. And I'd have a lot more respect for it's fans if they just admitted that's what they want. Saying you watch Queen's Blade for the plot is just... disingenuous.

But whatever. If companies have to sell 10,000 copies of Half-Naked Ninja Girls Season 2 for me to get Madoka Magica and Steins;Gate blu-rays, by all means bring on the boobies.

That probably came out meaner and rantier than I wanted, but it's like 1AM so...

___________________________________________

      

                   Don't forget. Always, somewhere, someone is fighting for you. 
                   As long as you remember Her, you are not alone.

view counter